Liv Tyler (97) (The Strangers)
See? I even found an incredibly dark, yellow horror flick easier to icon! Anyway. Liv was abso-frickin-gorgeous in this one, and it was ... probably the best horror/thriller I've ever, ever seen. It basically reduced me to a weeping gibbering mess on my housemate's arm.
No spoilers here, since when I was rewatching it to get screencaps -- on mute, with happy music in the background -- my nerves gave out halfway through. Which means I stopped capping right before all the crazy stuff started happening.